Love Medicine

Love Medicine
Detail of beadwork from an Ojibwe medicine pouch

Friday, February 22, 2008

Native American's

Why are all of these stories depressing? I want to read a successful story about Native Americans.

31 comments:

THA DENN-MISTER! said...

i like these stories, they make me feel better about myself! just kidding but these sad books have more drama and hidden sybolism in them

tilly billman said...

i agree, though these stories are very depressing there is alot of different aspects to look into it

Jordan Harry said...

i think they are depressing because the last 150 years of the rich Decadent culture of Native Americans has been so depressing

Shayan said...

they are depressing for a reason to draw attention to the condition.

Shayan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
brian said...

i think theres lots of sad stories about native americans but there are also stories of triumph about native americans showing how they were better people than the people that killed them

alex hump said...

i don't think i'd call the native american culture "decadent", i think i get what you're trying to say though

Trevinator said...

Jordan, you are wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong wrongwrongwrongwrongwrongwrongwrong.

Jack Truett said...

i second that trevor

Shayan said...

Jordan, these stories really just deal with internal issues and really have no correlation to their depressing past. Like little love stories and stuff.

Shayan said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
BHidalgo07 said...

I think a lot of truth is depressing because life isn't perfect so if all the stories were all happy then it would not be realistic and no one would be able to relate to a perfect life.

glossi said...

I like these stories, i agree that they're sad but i feel like they're more honest that way. and i don't think that just because these stories are sad it shows that native americans are unsuccessful

nitsudd said...

yeah jordan...not so much. "rich" and "decadent" are not the right adjectives i think you were looking for but i get what you are trying to understand.. it is depressing

Wade said...

yeah i think the stories or all sad because that pretty much how their life went, becuase as soon as whites showed up in their life, it pretty much sucked after that

bkorrapati25 said...

many of these stories we've read confirm all the negative stereotypes about Natives and give the reader a reason to believe the stereotypes. maybe the Indian authors write from real life experiences involving racism, poverty, and alcoholism

Macie said...

i think they're sad because it can help people relate to it or to help others deal with the same situation

Anonymous said...

When I was little my therapist would tell me to let out all my sadness by writing things down and when I would write stories or poems they would all be depressing because when I was depressed I wrote the most. Maybe people write depressing things because sad times are the easiest thing to write about and more people can connect to sadness than joy. Writing can be a way to let out all of the stuff locked up inside. Successful and uplifting stories sound cheesy. If that makes sense to yall.

Hallie said...

I actually like reading depressing stories. I think they're interesting and they make you really think about real life tragedies. On the other hand, though, I totally understand that it gets frustrating to read about the main characters fail all the time...

Laurie said...

I agree with Rudie and Hallie. I like reading these stories because they seem like they could be real. Life isn't all rainbows and unicorns, you know? You can relate to the sadness in the stories. If the stories were mushy love stories, we'd probably be complaining about that too - because it's not realistic. If everything in the story fell perfectly into place, it wouldn't be interesting because we couldn't relate to it.

Thomas Meric said...

i agree laurie. i think most of the time life kicks our butt and its what we do in spite of that that matters. i think this books tries to teach show us that

Kevin Quizzle said...

life is a garden..dig it..

life is tough..deal with it..these stories are really rich and entertaining..they are honest and truthful...nothing wrong with that

Anonymous said...

i agree with stephanie. its seems like the sader/ more depresing the book is the more symbolism it contains.

Jessika Whitbeck said...

Even though this story is really sad, it does contain a lot of symbolism. It portrays real life which is sometimes harsh and depressing.

sophie said...

well i think that the story of native americans is a depressing one because they lost their land and heritage because the white man and native americans could not live together and n.a. got the short end of the stick.

sophie said...

well i think that the story of native americans is a depressing one because they lost their land and heritage because the white man and native americans could not live together and n.a. got the short end of the stick.

seelige said...

i think the author wrote these stories to be depressing is because the author wants t oshow teh reader the true reality of the native americans, what they went through and how they felt

Ed Watts said...

Thats true, but sad stories don't just happent in Native American novels. Its just that we haven't read happy stoies, yet we have only read 2.

bossier330 said...

i think the stories are sad for the same reason news corporations only show shocking, terrible news...it makes money, not to say that this book is solely about money though.

michelleb said...

i think that because they are depressing thats what makes these stories interesting. If everything in every chapter was happy like rainbows and butterflies i would have no interest to continue reading

ethan mcraney said...

i totally agree michelle